How to Balance a Dairy Cow Ration Step by Step: Worked Example with Indian Feeds

To balance a dairy cow ration, work in this order: estimate dry matter intake (DMI), set the nutrient targets, choose the forage-to-concentrate split, calculate how much protein the concentrate mix must supply, use the Pearson square to blend the concentrate ingredients, then check energy, minerals and the as-fed weights. This article walks through all of it with one fully worked example using Indian feeds, and every number was checked by calculation.

If you only need to evaluate an existing ration, try our ruminant ration evaluator. If you want to learn the method by hand, read on.

The big idea: supply versus demand

Ration formulation is bookkeeping. The animal’s demand is the nutrients it needs (energy, protein, calcium, phosphorus and so on). The supply is what the chosen feeds provide. Extension guides describe the same four stages: describe the animal and find its requirements, list the feeds with their composition on a dry matter basis, choose a balancing method (Pearson square, substitution or computer), and check the result against each nutrient.

Does it really pay? What India’s ration balancing programme found

Feed makes up roughly 70 per cent of the cost of producing milk, according to NDDB. Its Ration Balancing Programme reached 33,374 villages and 28.65 lakh dairy animals in 18 states, advising farmers to adjust the quantities of the feeds they already had. The reported averages:

Two charts of NDDB Ration Balancing Programme results: milk per kg of feed dry matter rose from 0.58 to 0.78 in cows and from 0.53 to 0.66 in buffaloes, and average net income rose by Rs 25.5 per animal per day, made up of Rs 16.3 lower feed cost and Rs 9.2 from more milk and fat
Averages reported by NDDB; individual farms vary. Chart by Dr. Rameez Bloch, DrblochVet.com.
  • More milk from the same feed: milk per kg of dry matter eaten rose from 0.58 to 0.78 in cows and from 0.53 to 0.66 in buffaloes.
  • Better income: an average of Rs 25.5 more net income per animal per day, of which Rs 16.3 came from lower feed cost and Rs 9.2 from more milk and fat. Feed cost per kg of milk fell by about 11.8 per cent.
  • Longer lactations and less methane: lactations were about 26 days longer in cows and 50 days longer in buffaloes, and methane per kg of milk fell by an average of 13.7 per cent.
  • Typical errors on small farms: in a field study, 71 per cent of animals were eating more crude protein and energy than they needed, while 65 per cent were short of calcium and phosphorus. This is the same lesson as Step 8 below: protein and energy can look right while the minerals do not.

The method below is the manual version of what NDDB’s software does. Its inputs are the animal’s profile, milk yield, fat per cent, body weight, lactation stage and pregnancy status, and it checks dry matter, crude protein, TDN, calcium and phosphorus, the same five targets you will use.

Step 1: Estimate dry matter intake

Cows eat to a dry matter limit, not a fresh weight limit. A commonly used thumb rule is about 3 kg of dry feed per 100 kg body weight (the US worksheet states it as 3 lb per 100 lb). Another guide estimates forage intake as 120 divided by the forage’s NDF percentage, expressed as percent of body weight, so a 55% NDF forage is eaten in larger amounts than a 70% NDF one. Real intake varies with milk yield, stage of lactation, forage quality and heat, so treat the thumb rule as a starting point.

Example cow: 450 kg body weight. DMI = 450 x 0.03 = 13.5 kg dry matter per day.

Step 2: Set the nutrient targets

Proper requirements come from a feeding standard for the animal’s weight, milk yield and fat percentage (in India, ICAR feeding standards; internationally, NRC tables). For this teaching example we use thumb-rule targets from a university extension guide, expressed as percent of ration dry matter.

NutrientThumb-rule target
Crude protein (CP)About 14% of ration DM (range roughly 13 to 16%)
Energy (TDN)About 60 to 70% of ration DM
Roughage and grainEach at least one-third of DM
CalciumAbout 0.5% of dry ration
PhosphorusAbout 0.4% of dry ration
Ca : P ratio2 to 3 : 1 acceptable; 6 to 9 : 1 undesirable
Salt0.5 to 1% of grain mix, plus free choice
Urea (if used)Not more than about 1% of grain mix
MolassesNot more than about 5% of grain mix

For our cow: CP target = 0.14 x 13.5 = 1.89 kg. TDN target = 0.65 x 13.5 = 8.775 kg. Calcium = 0.5% of 13.5 kg = 67.5 g. Phosphorus = 0.4% of 13.5 kg = 54 g.

Step 3: List feeds on a dry matter basis

Compare feeds on dry matter, otherwise fresh green fodder will always look poor. The values below are illustrative figures typical of Indian feeds and are used only to teach the method. Always substitute values from a laboratory analysis or the ICAR/NIANP feed composition tables for your own feeds.

FeedDM %CP % of DMTDN % of DMCa % of DMP % of DM
Berseem (green)1518621.50.30
Green maize / sorghum258580.300.25
Wheat straw903.5400.250.07
Maize grain909800.030.30
Groundnut cake (GNC)9245800.200.65

Step 4: Split forage and concentrate

Cows need effective fibre to keep the rumen healthy, so start from forage. We choose 60% forage and 40% concentrate on a DM basis, which satisfies the “at least one-third each” rule. Forage DM = 8.1 kg; concentrate DM = 5.4 kg.

Choose the forages. We use 20 kg fresh berseem, 12 kg fresh green maize and 2.33 kg wheat straw. Convert to DM (fresh weight x DM%): berseem 3.0 kg, green maize 3.0 kg, straw about 2.1 kg. Total forage DM is about 8.1 kg, as planned.

ForageFresh (kg)DM (kg)CP (kg)TDN (kg)
Berseem203.000.5401.860
Green maize123.000.2401.740
Wheat straw2.332.100.0730.839
Forage total34.338.100.8534.439

The forage mix is therefore 0.853 / 8.097 = about 10.5% CP.

Step 5: How much protein must the concentrate carry?

Total CP needed is 1.89 kg. Forage supplies 0.853 kg, so the concentrate must supply 1.89 – 0.853 = 1.037 kg of CP from 5.4 kg of DM. Required concentrate CP = 1.037 / 5.4 = about 19.2%.

Step 6: The Pearson square for the concentrate mix

The Pearson square (box method) blends exactly two feeds to hit one target. Put the target in the centre, the two feeds’ values on the left, then subtract diagonally (ignore signs). Each right-hand number is the number of “parts” of the feed on the opposite side.

  1. Left top: maize grain, 9% CP. Left bottom: groundnut cake, 45% CP. Centre: target, 19.2%.
  2. Maize parts = 45 – 19.2 = 25.8. GNC parts = 19.2 – 9 = 10.2.
  3. Total parts = 25.8 + 10.2 = 36.
  4. Maize share = 25.8 / 36 = 71.7%. GNC share = 10.2 / 36 = 28.3%.
  5. Rounded: 72 kg maize and 28 kg GNC per 100 kg of grain mix.
  6. Check: 72 x 0.09 + 28 x 0.45 = 6.48 + 12.6 = 19.08 kg CP per 100 kg, i.e. about 19.1% CP.

The target must lie between the two feeds’ values, otherwise one share is negative. For a simpler check from an extension example: a 20% CP feed and a 31% CP feed to make 28% CP gives 3 / 11 = 27.3% of the first and 8 / 11 = 72.7% of the second. Our separate guide on the Pearson square, step by step gives more practice.

Step 7: Convert the mix to daily amounts

Concentrate DM is 5.4 kg: maize 72% = 3.888 kg DM, GNC 28% = 1.512 kg DM. Convert to as-fed by dividing by the DM fraction: maize 3.888 / 0.90 = 4.32 kg; GNC 1.512 / 0.92 = about 1.64 kg.

Step 8: Check the final ration against the targets

FeedAs-fed (kg)DM (kg)CP (kg)TDN (kg)Ca (g)P (g)
Berseem203.000.5401.86045.09.0
Green maize123.000.2401.7409.07.5
Wheat straw2.332.100.0730.8395.21.5
Maize grain4.323.890.3503.1101.211.7
GNC1.641.510.6791.2073.09.8
Total40.2913.491.8828.75663.439.4
Target13.51.898.77567.554
  • DM: 13.49 kg, on target.
  • CP: 1.882 / 13.49 = about 13.9%, on target.
  • TDN: 8.756 / 13.49 = about 64.9%, on target.
  • Calcium: 63.4 g (about 0.47% of DM), slightly below 0.5%.
  • Phosphorus: 39.4 g (about 0.29% of DM) against a 0.4% target, a gap of roughly 15 g. The Ca : P ratio is about 1.6 : 1, which is below the 2 to 3 : 1 guide.

This is exactly why you must check minerals separately: protein and energy balanced, phosphorus did not. The fix is a mineral mixture (and common salt) chosen from the label to close the calcium and phosphorus gap, for example about 1% mineral mixture and 1% salt in the grain mix as the extension guide suggests. Check the label for calcium and phosphorus content and adjust. Exact quantities per treating veterinarian or nutritionist.

Quick reference: the whole method on one page

StepQuestionOur answer
1How much dry matter can she eat?13.5 kg (3% of 450 kg)
2What do we need to supply?1.89 kg CP, 8.775 kg TDN, 67.5 g Ca, 54 g P
3What feeds are available, on DM basis?Table above
4Forage or concentrate share?60 : 40 (8.1 and 5.4 kg DM)
5CP the concentrate must carry?about 19.2%
6Pearson square72% maize : 28% GNC
7Convert to as-fed4.32 kg maize, 1.64 kg GNC
8Check all nutrientsCP and TDN on target; Ca and P low, add mineral mixture

Common mistakes in ration formulation

  • Mixing fresh and dry matter values. A feed’s CP percent is compared on DM; berseem at 18% of DM is only about 2.7% of fresh weight.
  • Forgetting the intake ceiling. You cannot just add grain; adding feed beyond the DMI limit means something must be replaced. Intake of forage also falls when more grain is fed (one guide notes roughly 6 to 7 lb less forage per extra 10 lb of grain).
  • Balancing only protein. A Pearson square balances one nutrient at a time. Check energy, calcium and phosphorus afterwards, as our example shows.
  • Using the square with more than two feeds without care. It works cleanly for two; for more, blend step by step or use a spreadsheet.
  • Using book values for everything. Tabulated values are less accurate than an analysis of your own fodder.
  • Forgetting to convert back to as-fed. Farmers weigh feed as fed, so always convert.
  • Ignoring roughage quality. Brown or old hay can be low in vitamin A, and very fine grinding hurts rumen function.

Indian feeds worth knowing

  • Green fodder: berseem, lucerne, maize, sorghum, hybrid napier, cowpea. Legumes carry more protein; cereal and grass fodders more energy per rupee.
  • Dry roughage: wheat straw, paddy straw, sorghum and maize stover. Low in protein and digestibility, useful for fibre.
  • Energy concentrates: maize, broken rice, wheat, bajra, rice polish, molasses (limit to about 5% of the grain mix).
  • Protein concentrates: groundnut cake, mustard cake, cottonseed cake, soybean meal, coconut cake.
  • By-products: wheat bran, rice bran, deoiled rice bran, chuni, depending on local price and quality.
  • Supplements: area-specific mineral mixture, common salt and, where recommended, a bypass or rumen-protected source.

For the theory behind these groups, see our animal nutrition notes and the page on minerals and vitamins in animal nutrition.

Memory aid

“D-R-F-C-P-M”: Dry matter, Requirements, Forage first, Concentrate share, Pearson, Minerals check. Say it as “Don’t Rush, Feed Carefully, Prove, Measure”. The two golden rules: always work in dry matter, and always check minerals last.

Frequently asked questions

How much dry matter does a dairy cow eat per day?

A thumb rule is about 3% of body weight as dry matter, so roughly 13.5 kg for a 450 kg cow. Real intake depends on milk yield, forage quality and climate.

Can I use the Pearson square for more than two feeds?

Yes, by treating a pre-mixed combination as one “feed” and running a second square, but precision drops. Spreadsheets or least-cost software handle many feeds and nutrients at once.

Why convert to dry matter at all?

Feeds contain very different amounts of water. Only on a DM basis can green berseem, straw and cake be compared fairly with requirements.

Is the ration in this example suitable for my cow?

Not directly. It demonstrates the method with thumb-rule targets. A real ration should use requirements for your cow’s weight, milk yield, fat and stage of lactation, and the analysed composition of your feeds, with advice from your veterinarian or a nutritionist.

Test yourself

  1. Q: What is the DMI of a 500 kg cow by the 3% rule?
    A: 500 x 0.03 = 15 kg DM.
  2. Q: A grain mix must be 16% CP using 9% maize and 44% soybean meal. What are the shares?
    A: Maize parts = 44 – 16 = 28; soybean parts = 16 – 9 = 7; total 35; so 80% maize and 20% soybean meal.
  3. Q: You need 5 kg DM of GNC (92% DM). How much do you weigh as fed?
    A: 5 / 0.92 = about 5.43 kg.
  4. Q: Why must you check minerals after balancing for protein and energy?
    A: The Pearson square balances one nutrient at a time, so calcium and phosphorus can still be short, as in the worked example.

Want more exam-oriented practice? See our livestock production management book and our guide on how to study veterinary MCQs.

Sources and further reading

  • National Dairy Development Board (NDDB): Ration Balancing Programme, the source of the village and animal counts, the income, feed-cost and methane figures, and the longer lactation reported.
  • NDDB: Ration Balancing under the National Dairy Plan I, including the estimate that about 70 per cent of the cost of milk production is feed.
  • NDDB: Ration Balancing Programme leaflet (the inputs used: animal profile, milk yield, fat per cent, body weight, lactation stage and pregnancy status; requirements assessed for dry matter, crude protein, TDN, calcium and phosphorus).
  • “Effects of feeding nutritionally balanced rations on animal productivity, feed conversion efficiency, feed nitrogen use efficiency, rumen microbial protein supply, parasitic load, immunity and enteric methane emissions of milking animals under field conditions”, Animal Feed Science and Technology, volume 179, pages 24 to 35 (the field study behind the feed-efficiency and calcium and phosphorus findings).
  • ICAR feeding standards and NRC dairy tables, for the requirements of your own animal’s weight, milk yield and fat per cent.

Reviewed by Dr. Rameez Bloch, BVSc & AH, MVSc (Gujarat Veterinary Council Reg. 3570). Last reviewed: November 2026. The worked example uses teaching figures; confirm requirements, feed values and any supplement or additive with a current veterinary formulary and your own feed analysis.